Make something
Email yourself a 10% off coupon
Send
Coupon sent! Check your email
0
Pros and Cons of Different Support Types
Hey guy, I only have messed with the makerware support structure that is like a zig zag design that takes up much time and can be tough to clean up.

Im about to purchase the simplify3d and the support material seems to be similar. I see other programs do a "Tree" like support structure. I think meshmixer does this.

My question is what do yall think is a better support structure method. Zig Zag Accordion looking support or Tree with branches support? or any other that you have heard of?
0
labtopia - what printer do you have, if its new gen mbi (i have 5gen) you cant use any other software and the makerbot desktop is extremely neutered. i am not sure if symplify will let you generate support then export an stl for this. im getting around this by generating support in materialize. cones seem to work best for me with this printer. i agree mbi support is not good since it's a pain to get off cleanly and you cant edit the support (if you know you dont need it somewhere)
9 years, 5 months ago
0
n23d - I often build my own in cad. Round pillars 1 to 2mm in diameter spaced from each other so they do not bond into one solid clump. They break off easy and leave small surfaces to clean up. Not fast to do but effective and right where they are needed.
9 years, 5 months ago
0
vinnie90 - I have 2 makerbots rep 2 and one makerbot rep 2x

You can run different slicing software on it. I have ran kisslicer and slic3r already on it in the past. I like makerbot slicer because it just works really easy. Simplify3d can generate support and even be able to customize where you put it. Blogs and videos say how easy it is to rip off. (Does this affect the look of the part??? IDK)

Just curious on the different support types out there. Which ones everyone likes and why.
9 years, 5 months ago
0
elpulpo - FWIW my Up! software gives me very little control over support structure. It's proprietary after all BUT it's very easy to remove and leaves a bare minimum of marks on the surface of the print, requiring very little cleanup. This pic should give you an idea what the support structure looks like..

http://www.makexyz.com/store/3d-printed-120mm-statuette-portrait-1d820e27afc0e61f463f40710cb0b1ae

Think it's probably what you called "Zig Zag Accordion" style, although, as you can see, the last few Millimetres before the surface of the print are more solid and a defined gap exists at the top of that.

I'd criticise Up! for a good many things but not their support. I've never seen anything as good.
9 years, 5 months ago
0
elpulpo - FWIW my Up! software gives me very little control over support structure. It's proprietary after all BUT it's very easy to remove and leaves a bare minimum of marks on the surface of the print, requiring very little cleanup. This pic should give you an idea what the support structure looks like..

http://www.makexyz.com/store/3d-printed-120mm-statuette-portrait-1d820e27afc0e61f463f40710cb0b1ae

Think it's probably what you called "Zig Zag Accordion" style, although, as you can see, the last few Millimetres before the surface of the print are more solid and a defined gap exists at the top of that.

I'd criticise Up! for a good many things but not their support. I've never seen anything as good.
9 years, 5 months ago
0
ashley@3dprintvancouver.com - Apparently Craftware does some pretty good support also, including the option of tree branches, and it's a free slicer. I've been meaning to try it.
9 years, 5 months ago
0
sd3dprinting - Simplify3D has the best customization of support structures by far, allowing you you to get clean surface lines for single material machines. It allows you to specify specific interface layers, XY distance, pillar resolution and fill density. It also allows you to remove any unnecessary structures that are auto generated (extremely important for thin walled pieces). If you just need support in a single pesky area, you can create the pillars yourself in Simplify in a matter of seconds.

The only issue with Simplify is that it is misnamed; its not simple to use at all. It's really meant for advanced users to fully utilize all of its functionality. Beginners can be easily overwhelmed by the amount of options it offers compared to Makerware, Cura, Slic3r and many of the other alternatives. If you know what you are doing though, it is well worth the money and can save you a great deal of frustration by allowing you to finely tune material specific print profiles.
9 years, 5 months ago
0
evan_lee - I've used MeshMixer support with pretty decent results after some tweaking. Slic3r support still trips me (and my printers) up sometimes, it's kinda hit or miss, but lately I've been having success with it.
9 years, 5 months ago
0
ashwin - All the knowledge about windows 10 operating system computer is available here and you have to join http://gethelpwindows10.com to get all of that easily.
4 years, 8 months ago
0
janetteeturnerr - Great post with a comparison. Many do not know how to write comparison texts. I advise such people to turn to the site https://www.collegepaperworld.com/do-my-homework.html which will write you an essay with the pros and cons.
3 years, 7 months ago
0
tais - I think that in order to have a successful online store and get professional support for your business, you need to look for a quick and non-standard solution. Perhaps the idea of obtaining outsourcing services will be beneficial to you? I advise you to calculate the costs of organizing a support center and look on this site https://wow24-7.io/ what conditions an outsourcing company can offer you.
3 years, 6 months ago
0
tais - This is a really very important question. I think that in order to have a successful online store and get professional support for your business, you need to look for a quick and non-standard solution. Perhaps the idea of obtaining outsourcing services will be beneficial to you? I advise you to calculate the costs of organizing a support center and look on this site https://wow24-7.io/ what conditions an outsourcing company can offer you.
3 years, 6 months ago
0
kerrycooper - Hello! If you see that you have no time for writing papers then it's time to use additional help like an essay writing service. Here is one page that is called https://exclusive-paper.net/white-paper-writing-services.php and there you can get all the necessary information.
3 years, 1 month ago
0
asdfasdf1@ - As a WordPress user, you may have noticed that the standard support service of your hosting company is not going to cut it when it comes to large and complex projects. You can get https://kranepoolsociety.com new things about sports. Even with their support staff at your disposal, you’ll still have to deal with issues critical to the final product. In this article, I’ll be discussing the pros and cons of different types of support services so you can make an informed decision when selecting a support option for your upcoming project
1 year, 5 months ago
Want to add a comment? Join the makexyz community.
Sign in