Make something
Email yourself a 10% off coupon
Send
Coupon sent! Check your email
1
So many requests for quotes, no money.
Seems like people are just want to know the price to print (sans one 4 day failed print), then no response.
Is there a way to find out how many quotes/purchases a person has?

Taken my printer off the makexyz, since its large (16"X16"X9") and people ask for large builds, then never respond. Been charging the lowest price acceptable on MakeXYZ, so it's not about price or response time.
0
snavazio - Also, I work near New York City (Offered NYC delivery). So location shouldn't be an issue either. FYI
9 years, 10 months ago
1
elpulpo - Yeah. There seem to be a few "Tyre kickers" lurking around. May even be competitors but I figure everything starts slowly. It's just a matter of sticking to it. :-D

Cheers!

Andy
9 years, 10 months ago
0
snavazio - Thanks Andy,

But I've taken my printer off. After 10+ quotes and no income, I'm wonder if other large build volume people are having the same issue?

Yesterday it happened again. A guy calls, he lives a mile from me and is excited to work together, says he'll send the file right over. Then nothing.

Seems like the market place is too immature.

Forget about repeat customers.

Pardon my rant, really wondering, though.

Steve
9 years, 10 months ago
3
elpulpo - Hey Steve, Well, that's weird but, in those circumstances, I'd usually send the guy a message reminding him to send the file and asking if he had any more questions. Put the ball in his court but give him the benefit of the doubt. Andy
9 years, 10 months ago
0
tjones - I'd say that over the past year, my conversion rate from inquiry to sale is 1 out of 3? or 1 out of 4? it definitely takes following up sometimes though, and there are of course always customers that get apathetic once it's time to type in their credit cart. but that's the game I guess.
9 years, 10 months ago
0
snavazio - @andy.-Thanks, Did it. He wrote back and sadi he'll send it shortly.

@TJ- Thanks, May I ask how large your print bed is?
9 years, 10 months ago
0
elpulpo - Shame on you, Steve! Asking such personal questions! Size isn't everything , ya know! :-D

Glad to hear you followed up with the customer. Apparently 25 years working in a sales environment had some compensations! :-)

@TJ: Judging by your 1:3 conversion rate I guess my next job should be the next customer to contact me! :-D

Cheers!

AndyL
9 years, 10 months ago
0
snavazio - Very funny Andy. Most of my print quotes over $100, $300 is not unusual. People just get shocked I'm thinking.
9 years, 10 months ago
1
jorge2222 - I can only think listing a few sample items with dimensions and price for those would help out limit the request for random quotes. I am here looking for 3D printing services and so far one quote requested but if I had a baseline I might not of needed to do that? What can alter the quote beyond the size? Is there any info to guide us 3D printer quote people?
9 years, 10 months ago
0
tanju-b - I haven't had an order since January, and am only getting about 1 inquiry per month.
9 years, 10 months ago
4
sd3dprinting - Just as a point of reference, we have definitely seen a wall at the $300 level. Above that just about everyone decides go to and try to buy their own printer. Then they find out all the intricacies of 3D printing by themselves and usually come back to us anyway. Just make sure to follow up with people to be there when they fall and they will find a way to get the money to you.
9 years, 10 months ago
0
sd3dprinting - It was this phenomenon that we noticed last year that gave us the idea for The Printer Farm: http://3dprint.com/5198/sd3d-3d-printer-farms-abe/

Expect this trend to continue as more affordable platforms get into the hands of non-traditional 3D printers (ie. people who don't know what open source is and couldn't assemble their printer to save their life)
9 years, 10 months ago
0
toybuilder - 1 out of 3 or 4 is about par for me these days. After a while, you get a sense of who are serious, and who are tire-kickers. It helps if your profile is more "professional" in terms of your requirements for what the customer submits.

Provide detailed breakdown of your quote. That'll help justify your price.

In your quote, provide the material volume and estimate time of print along with the material charge.

Separately note the setup, handling, and shipping charges (as applicable).

9 years, 10 months ago
0
snavazio - Jorge and Toybuilder - Thanks, great ideas, I'll take action and add my printer back onto Makexyz.

I must say, that it seems odd that nobody from Makexyz has jumped in here to help us/me out. This projection of the culture within the organization (lack of assistance), is disappointing.
9 years, 10 months ago
0
vinnie90 - I get a large amount of people as well that send messages and call for me to give quote. Once I tell them the price, then I hear nothing.

The majority of the time they want me to make the model and print it. No matter how simple it is it still takes time to sit and make this process happen. Then they hear the price, and I always try to let them know that 3D Printing is not as easy as the media is saying it is. People come up to me all the time thinking that it is as easy as me taking a pictures of something and pressing print.

People just need to be educated a little more. Only time will do this.
9 years, 10 months ago
0
snavazio - Hey Vinnie,
I agree, it appears that we (and Makexyz) need to be part of that equation also.IMHO

Like putting prices, time and weight on demo prints.
9 years, 10 months ago
0
draftynater - I believe I could help with peoples "no money" dilemma. Aside from drafting, I'm also in a family with a few Multi Level Network marketers and my brother is helping me build a business to earn residual income! I'm going to give it a shot, and still draft and someday soon actually get my own 3d printer...
9 years, 10 months ago
1
sirironduke - i too feel your pain. i have had many people just getting quotes. been on here for a long time, almost a year or so. did manage to get a paying bite tho. small 2 part job, but its something.
9 years, 10 months ago
1
jterrell - One thing I've gotten a whole lot of is that people have an object and want a copy made of it. They don't have a file or anything. I think they don't really know what 3D printing is.
9 years, 10 months ago
2
makerbeck - I have had people send a photo of something and ask, "can you print this?" The answer is often, "Yes, but it has to be designed first unless you have a model".

On the tire kickers, I often get people who in their minds are probably comparing a quote to what something costs at Home Depot, a Five and Dime, or some other purveyor of high volume products. It may not have crossed their mind that they will have to pay to have a design created or that the Home Depot price is based on tens of thousands of something being made in volume vs a one off customer job.
9 years, 10 months ago
0
snavazio - I love that "can you make this?" Haven't gotten that yet. The best I've had was someone asking for a price on a print that he was currently modifying. Knowing that he would ask for an updated price after the mod, it was implied he didn't value my time (as I do), after all the price quote was free for him(A.K.A. no value). I told him "I pass on quoting on obsolete parts and him finding someone else would be best for us both." We agreed, he hasn't been back.
9 years, 10 months ago
2
vinnie90 - ohh this thread can go on and on...lol

This wont get better until people FULLY understand what we have to do to make a print happen. I think only time will do this for us. Also if "News Stations" and "3D Printer companies" stop saying that "So Easy and So Fast and So Cheap"
9 years, 10 months ago
1
mkapras - How can companies sell printers to average Joes if they DON'T tell them "so easy, fast and cheap?"
9 years, 10 months ago
0
snavazio - @mkapras - It's called being transparent. Just like printing clients were asking for here. We have got to get past the "business as usual" perspective and understand that being open and honest has huge benefits, past making a quick buck. A great example of this is "Money Back" guarantee, it's a proven fact that businesses that stand behind their product generate more sales. Is there some problem with being open and honest before the sale?
9 years, 10 months ago
0
mkapras - Didn't mean to upset you... My comment was pure sarcasm. I agree with you completely!
9 years, 10 months ago
0
snavazio - Pardon me, I knew it was sarcastic. Just , many people still hold that type of belief.Thanks for the clarification,though. :)
9 years, 10 months ago
0
vinnie90 - I am still getting messages but no one is "pulling the trigger".

I just offered to do some parts for REALLY cheap, because I have nothing in the machines and it wouldnt hurt to make a couple of bucks. I get no reply....
9 years, 9 months ago
0
fixedtrd - Seem like most of them just want quotes then once they find the cheapest that's the one they go with. I'm pretty firm on our price.
9 years, 9 months ago
0
vinnie90 - Yea, I understand that because I would do the same. Im really firm as well, but dam someone must be breaking even with some of these prints...lol
9 years, 9 months ago
2
defcon3d - I've been following this post since inception... Here's my 2-cents...

I don't deal with perspective clients through the phones anymore. Only email now. Not worth my time to waste on someone that is just price shopping.

Once a relationship has been established then next time they have direct access via phone.

The guys that are serious are the one's that will take the time to explain to you about the part/parts for the quote in question.

I ask many questions through numerous emails before a quote. I can usually get a good feel if the person is blowing smoke or is a viable client.

On guys that want design work. I only quote based on a face to face. In the long run it saves so much time and energy. If I guy doesn't show at the agreed time then nothing is lost. He wasn't serious anyway. For all I know he could of been another printer just trolling for free info. :)

People will run you ragged if you let them. Will this attitude cause you to lose some work? It probably will, for the few small dollar parts.

But the guys that are engineers that are looking for a quick turnaround can make it all worth your while. Add to that the repeat business from these kinds of clients and you no longer care about a $20 part.

Once you get going, word of mouth will help your business to grow.

There are many guys that are desperate for work and will say anything to get the job. That's fine by me, If a real client isn't happy with fit and finish the guy may have gotten the first job but he won't get a second.

Guess, what I'm saying is you need to value yourself and your time.
This can turn into a legitimate business over time if you treat it as such. :)
9 years, 9 months ago
1
daewootech - Yeah I have had maybe 20+ inquiries with maybe 3-4 actual paying jobs. I try to respond quickly with as much info about print time, estimated cost, possible problematic areas in their designs and turnaround since I figure they ask everyone and only respond to the lowest bidder/ best answers. A lot of requests are items totally not printable or not even close to FDM optimized, a few I turned down because of complexity like that, but some prints I just go ahead and print the object and reply with the photos and price, if they say no then I have another item under my experience belt since just about every item had required specific settings for speed, temps, fill rates etc, and I use those for baselines for similar items.

The hard part is I charge mainly based on material usage and if a part if only like 5cm3 but complex as hell and I end up printing 10 of them until I feel it's ready to ship then I put all that time into something that will net me little to no money, won't even pay for the energy to run the machine for hours on end.
9 years, 9 months ago
1
diecast_dirtboy - I did a rather large design and print job. Got paid the first half but not the second and haven't heard from the guy for months. I''m kinda crossed about not getting paid and having crap laying around from the job.

Thanks
Colter
Additive Solutions
9 years, 9 months ago
1
defcon3d - @Colter...
That's the pits....
I try to collect at least my cost in the job up front. When it comes to design work that can be a whole other can of worms :)
9 years, 9 months ago
1
paulpapedesigns - I've been in the business of custom creating pieces for over a decade. This isn't anything new. When I did the trade show circuit the breakdown was always 100 lookers, 10 interested, 1 purchase. Since they are on this site for a reason, 1 in 3 is pretty good. I have a printer, a scanner, and a vacuformer. I also listed other pieces I make (hand sculpting and such) and the majority of my inquiries have been for that work. My pieces start at $300 and go up to a couple grand. The problem with the 3D print market is that it is a new market, the cost angle is goofy (since most people don't want to pay for your time, just the print, like in a box store), so as I see it, this is a pizza money kind of gig. I have found that the more images I put on my makexyz storefront the more inquires I get. And if all I'm wasting is the time to answer an email, I'm not out that much.
9 years, 9 months ago
2
pardimate - I figured I would throw in my perspective as a "potential" buyer, who contacted 4-5 different people and attached the STL files for my project, looking for a quote. The prices ranged from $120-$700 for this project, mostly it seems due to the cost for the printer to run. I didn't realize there was such a huge difference in operating costs for the 3D printers. I did respond to each of them letting them know what I decided within a couple of days. It sucks when people just don't get back to you, but I hope you'll stay on the site! Us newbies just don't know enough about 3D printing to not have to contact several people to get a feel for what is a fair price for the quality.
9 years, 9 months ago
0
angusgbishop - Nathan, I don;t know If you are following this, but it may be an Idea to post some details about the cost of prints on the front page, perhaps a little tool for a 'Rough quote' somewhere where users could drop an stl, and according to a set of parameters that the printers set, will drop out a rough idea of a quote +/- 20% This could include cost per cm3 and other overheads.

I find that in a lot of online stores like this, that quite a lot of people want zero contact with a human.

Just spitballing here though!
9 years, 9 months ago
0
labmaster - Just picking a printer should not be a flat cost. The detail in resolution, material choices, and size/finish are critical options. Some printer owners have no options so print only one material. Others of us have multiple printers, materials and finish options that are not available to distinguish our services easily as users who "shop around"...

My first responses are materials, detail and finish etc.

9 years, 9 months ago
0
dougcostlow - I feel if customers had to answer a few simple questions before sending messages to printers it could help everyone. Customers get a little better understanding of whats required and printers get better information up front. Questions like what service they are looking for, what material, how many parts, how soon is it needed, and what color would be a good start. Then messages don't have to go back and forth just for a quote to be provided.
9 years, 9 months ago
0
jtreg - I think we should NAME AND SHAME to timewasters and copy this to the administrator of this site - pople like Abbi1008.
9 years, 9 months ago
1
vinnie90 - jtreg I dont think they are doing this on purpose to waste our time. They are just doing what we do when we go to best buy for a tv. We walk around and look at all of them. Even the ones we know we cant afford. Then make a decision.

I think we should change this thread up from "people aren't replying back" to "Ideas on how to educate people on the cost of printing"

From reading this thread I believe and I think most of yall do as well, is that customers need to have a little more knowledge in printing BEFORE sending out quotes.Even if we have to subconsciously put it in their heads

Example: For them to send out a idea or stl they need to log in, fill out this form that has questions like resolution, color, material, print in one part, can print in multiple parts, quantity, etc. This way they see what we have to worry about,

If they dont know what something is then we can have some "?" on the end that will go into detail or show videos.

Once they have the form filled out they can save it as a name then send it to who ever they want. This form will show us everything that we need to know. Instead of a message that says "I need XXXXX Printed"
9 years, 9 months ago
0
jtreg - I still think when a person sends you stl files and a deadline with the expectation that I will print the files then you wonder what the point of this would be other than to 'wind up' the printing person and therefore I suggest a place on this site which make clear people who waste time by first of all asking for urgent requirements to be fulfilled then not even replying after that!
9 years, 9 months ago
0
tanju-b - Last year I suggested to Nathan that makexyz have some type of wiki section that we could all collectively create and maintain for the purpose of educating customers (and ourselves) with a lot of the info mentioned in this thread.

What do you guys think of that as an idea for the site?
9 years, 9 months ago
0
vinnie90 - Im definatly down for that idea. I dont think regular customer will go and read up on this stuff though.We gotta kinda "force" them in a way.
9 years, 9 months ago
0
jtreg - I still say have a blacklist
9 years, 9 months ago
0
jtreg - I still say have a blacklist as well
9 years, 9 months ago
0
elpulpo - Calm down jtreg. You'll give yourself an aneurism.

I have a suggestion ( Ahem! )

How about having a Pricing Panel? An open public area where prospective customers can upload a design and a panel of printers, from all over, discuss the design and agree on a price bracket. If such a panel were open to the public, prospective customers would be able to see what goes on behind the quote process and understand the kind of considerations that could reduce their costs. It would also enable us to modify expectations in the longer term

What do y'all think?
9 years, 9 months ago
0
angusgbishop - I am all up for being entirely transparent with my pricing process,
How do people add on their profit at the end, Do you do it as a % of final cost or a standard price?

I'm not sure I understand what you mean Andy, I have images of a council of elders style table where customers present stl's heads bowed and then we decide their fate.

I don't think adding questionnaires is the way to solve this, I know if I was looking for a service I would choose the one with minimum hassle and lowest price, If I had to sit down and fill out a 3 page questionnaire as to what I want I'm not sure Id go for it.
Perhaps we could add a header / reminder to the messages, when someone is first contacting the printer. Something like 'Please provide details of what the part needs to accomplish, any finishing needed etc'

I know it might mess up the design of the site, but I wonder if a small survey is worth undertaking 'How much would you expect to pay for X?'
9 years, 9 months ago
0
vinnie90 - Good ideas guys!

@angusgbishop...lmao about the old men at the table...I also see it in a dark dungeon with torches in the background...lol

Im down with any idea. If Nathan wants I think it would be a good idea to have some type of survey sent out to everyone customers and printers. Something that we can all vote on and possibly put more ideas into it. This way if you didnt participate then dont complain.

I think this site is awesome. I been on here for I think maybe a year or so and I have only made like $200. However, im not here to get rich. It is more of working with customers in building something for them, as well as talking to you guys.

I think we can all agree something needs to change. If anything can we at least try one idea. Possibly the easiest to do on the site. Once that is done, then after a good amount of time we can decide if it is working or not.
9 years, 9 months ago
0
angusgbishop - Yeah I think we can all agree that the reason so many quotes just aren't advanced is because costs come in higher than expected.
As I see it we just need to educate the customers before quote.
9 years, 9 months ago
0
elpulpo - Old men around the table sounds like an excellent idea to me! :-D

Nah. What I meant was that the prospective customer could upload a file and the "panel" could advise on such subjects as preprocessing required, most suitable printing technology, ideal orientation etc, whilst also setting a price expectation. Of course, this type of panel would be open to all kinds of abuse but most of that could be easily detected and the prospect that Nathan would come down on you like a ton of bricks should keep people sensible.

TBH, I'd have no objection to an auction-style system where customers put a job up for tender. Anything that would make it easy for me to judge whether the time and effort I put into MakeXYZ is worthwhile. Right now, that doesn't seem to be the case but it seems that the UK is slightly behind the US on the awareness curve.

Glad that I have other 3D-based strings to my bow or else I'd be destitute! LOL
9 years, 9 months ago
0
angusgbishop - Oh, so like a volunteer advice panel sort of thing?
So certain members could advise a prospective client without necessarily expecting money from it?
I'd be up for that.

I thought there was a job post button somewhere on the homepage.
9 years, 9 months ago
0
angusgbishop - Oh, so like a volunteer advice panel sort of thing?
So certain members could advise a prospective client without necessarily expecting money from it?
I'd be up for that.

I thought there was a job post button somewhere on the homepage.
9 years, 9 months ago
0
elpulpo - Yeah. That's the kinda thing! :-D
9 years, 9 months ago
0
elpulpo - Yeah. That's the kinda thing! :-D :-D
9 years, 9 months ago
0
louieaustin - This does not mean that you should give up, you need to continue to work, but only for yourself and with the help of https://www.mightytips.com/bookmakers/best-basketball-betting-sites/ that’s how you can have enough money and earn a lot more. I wish you only good luck and you will succeed with this site.
4 years, 3 months ago
0
allenwood - Our Salesforce ADM-201 Exam Dumps are comprehensive, precise and perfectly exam-oriented. You can prepare them within a few days’ effort only. Wherever you feel any confusion, you can contact our online team of professionals. They will respond to your queries efficiently. Preparing for exam with the help of DumpsLeader’s braindumps and study guides will prove a supportive & rewarding learning experience for you.

Get Demo: https://www.dumpsleader.com/ADM-201-exam-dumps.html
3 years, 2 months ago
0
david043 - Really structured and useful information. And everything is clear, thanks. I looked through some posts and must say, they are very <a href="https://sites.google.com/view/bestpaperwritingservices">https://sites.google.com/view/bestpaperwritingservices</a> interesting. Best regards, essay writer
3 years, 2 months ago
0
marvini - I am [url=https://www.makexyz.com/]new[/url]
2 years, 9 months ago
0
tomas7 - You have very cool 3D models. If you always want to know whether they will sell well or if you want to attract money to yourself, then I highly recommend you to use this site https://tarotreadingfree.com/two-of-wands-rider on which you can easily make layouts on tarot cards! This will allow you to always know what will happen in your future, as well as attract money!
2 years, 7 months ago
0
figo - metal production for small batch, quote it here, we will reply the quotation for metal cnc machining within 1 day.https://fiter-auto.com/.
2 years, 7 months ago
0
truewordingt - Another thing that can lead you to a despondent life is assumption. We expect such a huge amount from our life so that a tad of not getting what we expect can make u miserable. We ought to continuously deal with the way that it is preposterous to expect to get everything we need throughout everyday life.
https://truewordings.com/
1 year, 1 month ago
Want to add a comment? Join the makexyz community.
Sign in